The Kings Of Copan: in their own words, by Janice Van Cleve
If you still require more books The Kings Of Copan: In Their Own Words, By Janice Van Cleve as recommendations, going to browse the title as well as style in this site is offered. You will certainly locate more whole lots publications The Kings Of Copan: In Their Own Words, By Janice Van Cleve in various self-controls. You can also as soon as possible to review guide that is currently downloaded and install. Open it and also conserve The Kings Of Copan: In Their Own Words, By Janice Van Cleve in your disk or device. It will alleviate you wherever you need the book soft data to check out. This The Kings Of Copan: In Their Own Words, By Janice Van Cleve soft data to check out can be referral for everybody to boost the ability as well as ability.
The Kings Of Copan: in their own words, by Janice Van Cleve
Read Online Ebook The Kings Of Copan: in their own words, by Janice Van Cleve
This book offers many significant advantages to the student of Maya history. It gathers all of the available royal inscriptions of Copan in one place. It assigns the inscriptions to the correct kings. The drawings for each inscription have been cleaned up so the glyphs stand out clear and distinct. Each inscription has been gridded by letters and numbers for the exact location of each glyph. Every word has been translated or transliterated where possible. The author makes no pretense that these translations are the final word but at least now scholars have a single solid base from which to continue the work.
The Kings Of Copan: in their own words, by Janice Van Cleve- Amazon Sales Rank: #2977145 in Books
- Published on: 2015-10-27
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 10.00" h x .59" w x 8.00" l, 1.15 pounds
- Binding: Paperback
- 258 pages
About the Author Janice Van Cleve holds a Masters Degree in Medieval History with a minor in languages. After a career as a military intelligence officer in the US Army and twenty five years in the computer industry, she turned to archeology, and was drawn to the Maya. She has visited many Maya sites but focuses primarily on Copan in Honduras. This book is step in our ongoing understanding of Maya culture and history.
Where to Download The Kings Of Copan: in their own words, by Janice Van Cleve
Most helpful customer reviews
0 of 0 people found the following review helpful. Too detailed and analytical for the casual reader; not sure of quality By William R. Drake Although Van Cleve is not an archaeologist or a professional Mayan scholar, she has a personal connection to Copan and has studied it at some length. I have read a number of books on the city and the Mayan culture by the principal scholars that have written about them, so I have some familiarity with this area.The main point I want to make about the book is that it is not for the average reader who plans to visit Copan or just wants to learn something about Copan or the great city’s kings. A book that discusses Copan’s rulers and is much more suited to the casual reader is Chronicle of the Maya Kings and Queens by Simon Martin and Nikolai Grube (second ed.), and even that may be too detailed for some people. For an overview of Capan, William Fash’s Scribes, Warriors and Kings: The City of Copan and the Ancient Maya (revised ed.) might be of interest.Van Cleve’s book is like a lengthy research paper with an analysis of Copan’s hieroglyphs much more suited to a Copan researcher than the general public. (The author seems to acknowledge this in her preface, when she writes, “This book offers many significant advantages to the scholar.”) Although I am going to Copan in a few months and have studied a lot about that city, The Kings of Copan was too detailed and, in parts, too analytical for me to finish. This is not a criticism of the book. It is just to say that its focus was beyond me. What I would recommend to the author is that she make it clear on the back cover who her intended audience is. She could also state this more directly in the preface.The book appears to be very thorough, but I do not have the scholarly background necessary to assess its quality. It is obvious that the author has put an enormous amount of work into it. A friend of mine, who did field work at Mayan sites with Linda Schele and Peter Mathews, and who has extensively studied the Maya, was not impressed with The Kings of Copan. He does not like the style of her presentation and does not feel that the book is of the same quality as that of professional Mayan scholars or that the author makes a significant contribution beyond the work already done by Schele and Mathews (The Code of Kings, etc.), Bill Fash, and other professionals. Regarding the writer’s presentation style, I think my friend’s concern is that the book combines a narrative and an analytical (re: hieroglyphs) approach. A book for scholars might best be served by just focusing on hieroglyphs and the author’s interpretations. (It is true that books like Linda Schele’s and David Freidel’s A Forest of Kings and Maya Cosmos combine narrative [some of which is creative fiction] with scholarly research, but they appeal to a broader audience than just other scholars. Even the Code of Kings differs from The Kings of Copan. Schele and Mathews are not debating the meaning of specific glyphs and presenting analytical research papers.) Frankly, I would feel better about van Cleve’s book if it included endorsements by respected authorities in the field, and I encourage the author to work on getting several. Barbara or Bill Fash would be near the top of the list for meaningful endorsements, but endorsements by any respected archaeology professors who specialize in the Maya and are acquainted with the reading of Mayan hieroglyphs would be helpful. She could easily add the endorsements to her book as well as her Amazon page without having to do a revised edition. My concern is that her own credentials are, at best, rather weak (a master’s degree in Medieval history and a background in military intelligence). (Weak or “non existent” credentials do not necessarily mean that the book is inadequate, although it makes it more likely in the case of a book of this nature. But without a good resume, good endorsements would give the book credibility and would reassure a researcher that it is worth his/her time. Aside from the time involved for a researcher to study this book, it is relatively expensive.)I am not sure how many Amazon stars to give The Kings of Copan. I do not feel I am a fair judge of that. My decision on 3 stars is based, in part, on my friend’s assessment, and, in part, on the absence of a credible endorsement. What prompted me to even write a review, although this is not a very thorough one, is the fact that the only other review the book currently has – one which was a factor in my buying the book to begin with - would lead the average reader to think they might enjoy this book. I want to correct that impression.
0 of 0 people found the following review helpful. I',m on my way to Copan with this book as a wonderful resource. By John S Daigle I'm on my way to Copan on David Stuart's [...] and this well-written book will help me brush up on my glyphs for the Copan dynasty.
0 of 2 people found the following review helpful. A trip to the past: too fun to be serious, too detailed to be discounted By Ariele M. Huff Blessed to have been early involved with Janice Van Cleve's work, I find this latest addition a charming expansion and exploration. This is an intricate web of inter-connections between events, places, objects, and individuals. Nothing escapes her. Beyond that, all her books do better than most to bring an authentic feel to historical descriptions--life in a time so long ago. Nothing is dry or mundane in her re-creations. This is due, of course, to the author's relentless adoration of research but also to her ability to live in the times she studies. This is a person who brings the magic of sensing herself right into her era and area. She sets the puzzle of discoveries together with a zest, showing the reason for her passion in telling these stories. Another home run, Janice!
See all 3 customer reviews... The Kings Of Copan: in their own words, by Janice Van CleveThe Kings Of Copan: in their own words, by Janice Van Cleve PDF
The Kings Of Copan: in their own words, by Janice Van Cleve iBooks
The Kings Of Copan: in their own words, by Janice Van Cleve ePub
The Kings Of Copan: in their own words, by Janice Van Cleve rtf
The Kings Of Copan: in their own words, by Janice Van Cleve AZW
The Kings Of Copan: in their own words, by Janice Van Cleve Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar